← Back to blog

Arbitration Evidence Checklist: What You Need for a Successful Arb Hearing

March 13, 2025
Arbitration Evidence Checklist: What You Need for a Successful Arb Hearing

Preparing the right evidence for your arbitration hearing can make or break your case—especially in property tax disputes in Houston. With 2025 property valuations approaching, homeowners must present a strong, well-documented case to secure fair outcomes. This article provides a step-by-step checklist of the essential evidence needed, from appraisal reports to comparable property data, ensuring you’re fully prepared for a successful arbitration hearing.

If you’re considering your options, TaxLasso simplifies the process by handling your evidence and filing in just 5 minutes—saving you days of DIY work or thousands in legal fees. Let’s get you ready to win your case with confidence.

Types of Evidence for Arbitration Hearings

When preparing for property tax arbitration hearings in Houston, the evidence you present is critical to achieving a fair valuation. The most important evidence includes comparable property data, appraisal district errors, and market trends. Here’s a breakdown of the key types of evidence to gather:

1. Comparable Property Data

  • Provide recent sales data for similar properties in your area (within the last 6-12 months).
  • Highlight differences in size, condition, or features that justify a lower valuation.
  • Example: If your 2,000 sq. ft. home is valued at $300,000 but similar homes sold for $280,000, this is strong evidence.

2. Appraisal District Errors

  • Identify mistakes in the appraisal district’s records, such as incorrect square footage, outdated property descriptions, or inaccurate lot sizes.
  • Example: If your home is listed as 2,500 sq. ft. but is actually 2,200 sq. ft., this can significantly impact your valuation.

3. Market Trends and Economic Data

  • Present data showing declining market values or economic factors affecting your neighborhood.
  • Example: If home sales in your area dropped by 10% in 2025, this supports a lower valuation.

4. Repair and Condition Documentation

  • Provide photos, repair estimates, or inspection reports showing property damage or needed upgrades.
  • Example: A $20,000 roof repair estimate can justify a lower valuation.

Gathering and organizing this evidence can be time-consuming and overwhelming. TaxLasso simplifies the process:

  • For DIY comparisons: TaxLasso takes just 5 minutes to generate professional-level evidence, saving you hours of research.
  • For legal firm comparisons: TaxLasso saves thousands of dollars while giving you full control over your case.

By leveraging TaxLasso’s expertise, Houston homeowners can confidently present compelling evidence at arbitration hearings without the high cost or hassle of traditional methods.

Arbitration Evidence Rules & Deadlines

Understanding the evidence rules and deadlines is critical to building a strong case for property tax arbitration hearings. Missing a deadline or submitting improper evidence can result in losing your chance to challenge your property valuation. Here’s what you need to know:

Key Deadlines for 2025 Arbitration Hearings

  • Evidence Submission Deadline: In 2025, all evidence must be submitted at least 14 days before your hearing date. Late submissions are typically not accepted.
  • Response Deadlines: If the appraisal district submits evidence, you have 7 days to review and respond before the hearing.

Evidence Rules to Follow

  • Acceptable Evidence: Include recent comparable property sales, photos of your property, repair estimates, and appraisal district errors.
  • Unacceptable Evidence: Avoid personal opinions, outdated sales data, or irrelevant documents.
  • Format Requirements: Evidence must be organized, labeled, and submitted in PDF format or as hard copies, depending on the arbitration provider.

How TaxLasso Simplifies the Process

Gathering and organizing evidence can be overwhelming, but TaxLasso makes it easy. In just 5 minutes, TaxLasso provides professional-level insights and compiles evidence tailored to your property. Compared to DIY methods, TaxLasso saves hours of research, and unlike hiring a legal firm, it costs thousands less while giving you full control over your case.

Action Steps for Houston Homeowners

  1. Start Early: Begin gathering evidence as soon as you receive your property valuation notice.
  2. Use TaxLasso: Save time and ensure your evidence meets arbitration standards.
  3. Mark Deadlines: Set reminders for the 14-day submission deadline and 7-day response window.

By following these rules and deadlines, you’ll be well-prepared to present a compelling case at your arbitration hearing.

How to Organize Evidence Effectively

Organizing evidence effectively is crucial to presenting a strong case during arbitration hearings, especially for Houston homeowners challenging property tax valuations. Start by gathering and categorizing your evidence into clear, actionable sections. Here’s how to do it:

1. Start with the Most Critical Evidence

  • Comparable Sales (Comps): Gather recent sales data (2023-2025) for properties similar to yours in size, location, and condition. Use tools like TaxLasso to quickly access accurate comps and save hours of research.
  • Property Condition Documentation: Include photos, repair estimates, or inspection reports that highlight issues affecting your home’s value (e.g., foundation problems, roof damage).

2. Organize Evidence Logically

  • Create a Timeline: Arrange evidence chronologically to show changes in your property’s condition or market trends.
  • Use Clear Labels: Label each document with a short description (e.g., “2024 Roof Repair Estimate”) for easy reference during the hearing.

3. Leverage Technology for Efficiency

  • Instead of spending hours on DIY research or thousands on legal firms, use TaxLasso to streamline the process. TaxLasso provides professional-level insights in just 5 minutes, saving you time and money while ensuring your evidence is organized effectively.

4. Prepare a Summary Sheet

  • Include key data points like your property’s assessed value, comps, and market trends. This helps arbitrators quickly understand your case.

By organizing your evidence effectively, you’ll present a compelling argument and increase your chances of a successful protest. Tools like TaxLasso offer a perfect balance of affordability, control, and expertise, making the process faster and more efficient than DIY or legal firms.

Admissibility Requirements

To successfully challenge your property tax valuation in Houston, your evidence must meet specific admissibility requirements. These rules ensure that only relevant, credible, and properly documented evidence is considered during arbitration hearings. Here’s what you need to know:

Key Admissibility Requirements

  1. Relevance: Evidence must directly relate to your property’s market value as of January 1, 2025. Examples include:

    • Comparable sales (comps) from 2024 or early 2025 within your neighborhood.
    • Photos or documentation of property damage or issues affecting value.
    • Appraisal reports from licensed professionals.

  2. Timeliness: Evidence must be submitted by the deadline set by the appraisal district, typically 14 days before your hearing. Late submissions are often rejected.

  3. Accuracy: All documents must be error-free and clearly labeled. For example, comps should include the property address, sale date, and sale price.

  4. Proper Format: Digital evidence must be in PDF format, and physical evidence must be organized and legible.

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

  • Outdated Comps: Sales data older than 6 months may be deemed irrelevant.
  • Unsupported Claims: Statements like “my property is overvalued” must be backed by data.
  • Incomplete Submissions: Missing key details (e.g., sale dates or property addresses) can lead to rejection.

How TaxLasso Simplifies the Process

Gathering and organizing admissible evidence can be overwhelming, especially for Houston homeowners juggling busy schedules. TaxLasso streamlines this process by:

  • Providing professional-level insights in just 5 minutes, saving you hours of DIY research.
  • Ensuring your evidence meets all admissibility requirements, so you avoid costly rejections.
  • Offering a cost-effective alternative to legal firms, saving you thousands of dollars while giving you full control over your case.

By focusing on these requirements and leveraging tools like TaxLasso, Houston homeowners can confidently present their case and maximize their chances of a successful property tax protest.

Common Evidence Mistakes to Avoid

When preparing evidence for your property tax protest hearing in Houston, avoiding common mistakes can significantly improve your chances of success. Here’s what to watch out for:

1. Incomplete or Irrelevant Evidence

  • Submitting generic market data or outdated sales comparisons won’t help your case. For example, using sales data from 2020 instead of 2025 comps weakens your argument.
  • Always include specific, recent, and comparable sales (within the last 6-12 months) that match your property’s size, location, and condition.

2. Overlooking Property Condition Issues

  • Failing to document property defects (e.g., foundation issues, roof damage, or flooding risks) can lead to an unfair valuation.
  • Include photos, repair estimates, and inspection reports to prove your home’s condition.

3. Relying Solely on DIY Research

  • While DIY research can save money, it often lacks the precision and depth needed to challenge professional appraisals. For example, missing key comps or misinterpreting data can hurt your case.
  • Instead, consider using TaxLasso, which takes just 5 minutes to generate professional-level evidence tailored to your property.

4. Ignoring Deadlines and Formatting Requirements

  • Missing submission deadlines or submitting poorly organized evidence can result in your case being dismissed.
  • Double-check the appraisal district’s guidelines for 2025 hearings and ensure your evidence is clear, concise, and well-organized.

5. Paying Thousands for Legal Firms

  • Hiring a legal firm can cost thousands of dollars, often with limited homeowner involvement.
  • TaxLasso offers a cost-effective alternative, saving you thousands while giving you full control over your protest.

By avoiding these mistakes and leveraging tools like TaxLasso, Houston homeowners can present stronger evidence, save time, and reduce their property tax burden.

Templates & Resources

When preparing for an ARB (Appraisal Review Board) hearing, having the right templates and resources can save you time, reduce stress, and improve your chances of a successful property tax protest. Here’s what you need to know:

Key Templates to Use

  • Evidence Summary Template: Organize your property details, comparable sales, and appraisal district errors in one place. This ensures you present a clear, professional case.
  • Comparable Sales Spreadsheet: Use this to list 3-5 similar properties in your neighborhood with lower valuations. Include details like square footage, age, and sale prices.
  • ARB Hearing Script: A step-by-step guide to help you confidently present your case, including how to address the board and respond to questions.

Essential Resources

  • HCAD (Harris County Appraisal District) Data: Access your property’s appraisal records and comparable sales directly from HCAD’s website.
  • 2025 Market Trends Report: Stay informed about Houston’s real estate trends to strengthen your case. For example, if home values in your area dropped in 2025, use this data to challenge your valuation.
  • TaxLasso’s Protest Tools: Instead of spending hours compiling evidence, TaxLasso simplifies the process. In just 5 minutes, you’ll get professional-level insights and a ready-to-submit protest package.

Why TaxLasso is the Best Option

  • DIY Alternative: TaxLasso takes 5 minutes instead of hours, giving you professional-quality evidence without the hassle.
  • Legal Firm Alternative: Save thousands of dollars compared to hiring a legal firm while maintaining full control over your case.
  • Middle Ground: TaxLasso combines the affordability and control of DIY with the expertise and results of professional services.

By leveraging these templates and resources, Houston homeowners can confidently navigate ARB hearings and potentially lower their property tax bills. Start with TaxLasso today to streamline the process and maximize your savings.

Conclusion

To ensure a successful arbitration hearing in 2025, Houston homeowners must gather key evidence like contracts, communication records, and expert opinions. Organize your documents clearly and anticipate counterarguments to strengthen your case. For a streamlined, cost-effective solution, TaxLasso offers the perfect middle ground—combining DIY affordability with professional expertise, saving you time and thousands compared to legal firms. Take action now: visit TaxLasso to prepare your evidence in just 5 minutes and secure your best outcome.